Campbell summarized the legal challenges and the general court findings as of July While these traits, tendencies or abilities are not unique to Pit Bulls exclusively, Pit Bulls will have these instincts and phenotypical characteristics; most significantly, such characteristics can be latent and may appear without warning or provocation.
History of Breed-Specific Legislation Breed-Specific Legislation BSL is, in simple terms, a statute or regulation that is directed toward one or more specific breeds of dogs. Then, the only way to really make people safe from dogs would be to ban all dogs, but what does that accomplish: Enhanced enforcement of dog license laws, with adequate fees to augment animal control budgets and surcharges on ownership of unaltered dogs to help fund low-cost pet sterilization programs in the communities in which the fees are collected.
For example, in a decision, the Kansas Supreme Court held that an ordinance regulating the ownership of pit bulls within the city was permissible. Not only did the Obama family introduce Sunny the puppy to her adoring countrybut the White House also came out against breed-specific legislation -- regulations and laws that restrict ownership of dogs by breed, pit bulls being the most common target.
There is no evidence that breed-specific laws make communities safer for people or companion animals. As certain breeds are regulated, individuals who exploit aggression in dogs are likely to turn to other, unregulated breeds Sacks et al.
Another impetus for overturning breed bans has been cost. Even laws that ostensibly are only regulatory may impose a de facto ban on a breed, creating a climate where it is nearly impossible for residents to live with such breed, and virtually ensuring destruction of otherwise adoptable dogs by shelters and humane societies.
Based upon the substantial evidence presented at trial, this court finds that Dade County Ordinance No. Communities that have instituted such bans often find that the irresponsible owners and the criminals who use dogs for illegal purposes simply switch to another breed.
BSL identifies a dog as "dangerous" based upon its breed alone and not based on any action or offense that the individual dog has ever committed. In recent years, however, many state and local governments have adopted a new tactic for eliminating dog aggression.
Its Evolution, Behavior and Interactions with People. The consequences have been disastrous: Ina New Mexico town completely banned pit bulls and allowed county officers to confiscate and euthanize the dogs. The American Kennel Club AKCone of the most prominent canine organizations in the world, recently issued a position statement on breed-specific laws: Nearly all the laws, when implemented, included a "grandfather clause" which allowed current owners of the specified breeds to keep their dogs, but prohibited any prospective acquisitions or breeding.
Essay against breed specific legislation california 4 stars based on reviews. The Appeals court upheld the Bracken County ordinance, finding that 1 the breed-specific ordinance supplemented, rather than replaced or superseded, the definition of a "vicious dog" in the state statute; 2 the banning of pit bull terriers was permissible under the police power, and that property seized under the police power was not subject to compensation 3 dog owners had the right of appeal to the Circuit Court under the ordinance, so the right of due process was preserved; and 4 the ordinance did not discriminate against non-resident pit bull owners, and that the appellants had not provided any evidence that traveling with a pet "occupies a position fundamental to the concept of a federal union.
Laws that prohibit chaining or tethering taking care also to prohibit unreasonable confinement once a dog is removed from a chaincoupled with enhanced enforcement of animal cruelty and animal fighting laws. The American Kennel Club AKCone of the most prominent canine organizations in the world, recently issued a position statement on breed-specific laws: The Pulaski County circuit court made a summary judgment dismissing the suit, and Mr.
However, the theory underlying breed-specific laws—that some breeds bite more often and cause more damage than others, ergo laws targeting these breeds will decrease bite incidence and severity—has not met with success in practice. The trial court in Orleans Parish found for Mr.
Properly drafted it has a stronger legal and evidentiary basis. In short, the damages are usually such as are beyond the reach of judicial process, and legislation of a drastic nature is necessary to protect persons and property from destruction and annoyance.
City of Maumelle, S. ASPCA Position Although multiple communities have been studied where breed-specific legislation has been enacted, no convincing data indicates this strategy has succeeded anywhere to date Klaassen et al.
Money minded people essays Money minded people essays essaystate review33 ways to end an essay without saying in conclusion alternatives algorithmic trading research papers war poetry essay one boy self explanatory essay writing yksisarvinen unessay casterbridge critical essay mayor an essay on criticism tone deaf chrysalids essay unappetizing food essay journal malay wedding ceremony essays.
Demographic trends for animal care and control agencies in Ohio from to Here owners of pit bulls or other banned breeds argue that the breed ban laws do not adequately define just what is a "pit bull" or other banned breed for purposes of the ban.
While Pit Bulls are not the only breed of dog which can be dangerous or vicious, it is reasonable to single out the breed to anticipate and avoid the dangerous aggressiveness which may be undetectable in a Pit Bull. Breed-specific legislation and the pit bull terrier: Court cases challenging BSL have focused on constitutional concerns such as substantive due process, equal protection, and vagueness.
As stated before, how does making laws against dogs stop the people from introducing a different more dangerous dog. Certainly there are some applications of the ordinance which pass constitutional muster. Concerned dog lovers are encouraged to serve on or start animal control advisory boards to monitor problems and help develop reasonable solutions to dangerous dog issues.
Nov 24, · this was the final opening video for my power point presentation on an argumentative essay about pitbulls and BSL.
(breed specific legislation) Got an "A" on it. Position Statement on Breed-Specific Legislation. Background Despite the well-established strength of the human-animal bond (Wensley, ), exemplified by the nearly 74 million dogs kept as companion animals in the United States, coexistence is not always peaceful.
Aug 20, · "Breed-Specific Legislation Is a Bad Idea" begins the White House's official response to an online petition, signed by more than 30, people, asking for laws that target dogs by breed to be.
Animal cruelty essay thesis statement simba the king lion unity is strength essays victim essay. Essay against breed specific legislation california.
5 stars based on 87 reviews allianceimmobilier39.com Essay. Previous Post. Leave a comment. Click here to cancel reply. Name *.
Specific Purpose Statement: To invite my audience to explore the advantages, disadvantages, and the alternatives associated with breed specific legislation.
Thesis: Breed specific legislation is a controversial topic in which I am very interested and would like to explore both sides of the issue to perhaps learn something new.
Breed Specific Legislation (BSL) is defined as a law or statute that equates the qualities of a dangerous dog with a certain breed, and bans or restricts certain breeds based on identity, not behavior of .Breed specific legislation thesis statement